Research ProjectElevated Carbon Dioxide and Plant Communities

  • Bert Drake by experimental chamber

    Emeritus Scientist Bert Drake with one of his CO2 chambers

Description

The first experiment on the marsh, and the longest-running of its kind in the world, began in 1987 under the guidance of plant physiologist Bert Drake. By 1987, carbon dioxide (CO2) levels in the atmosphere had reached 350 parts per million. It was common knowledge that rising carbon dioxide stimulated plant growth, but it was unclear how this could shift the species makeup of a wetland—and how it would impact photosynthesis and plant growth over the long term.

Visit Global Change Research Wetland homepage

The Question

Most elevated CO2 studies before 1987 were in greenhouses. Dr. Drake performed his study in a real ecosystem, to find out how plants behaved in situ and discover how the wetland as a whole would respond to this single, but crucial, component of climate change. He centered his study around the wetland's two major plant species: the sedge Schoenoplectis americanus (then called Scirpus olneyi), with C3-type photosynthesis, and the grass Spartina patens, with C4-type photosynthesis. Based on previous research, Bert Drake expected elevated carbon dioxide to increase the growth of C3 plants but not C4 plants. But he questioned whether this growth benefit would persist over many years. The only previous study of elevated CO2 had taken place in an Arctic tundra, where the growth benefits of CO2 disappeared in a few years.

Methodology

Dr. Drake's team built 30 open-top chambers, each surrounding a small area (0.8m2) of marsh plants. Inside half the chambers, they raised the carbon dioxide concentration from 350 to 700 parts per million, effectively simulating predictions of carbon dioxide worldwide by the end of the 21st century. In total the experiment contained six types of experimental chambered plots: two CO2 treatments (elevated vs. ambient) around three plant communities (C3 Schoenoplectus, C4 Spartina and mixed). To control for chamber effects, the team also monitored 15 plots with no chambers.

Discoveries

Past experiments had shown that higher carbon dioxide stimulates C3 plants, but not C4 plants. Scientists expected Schoenoplectus to respond well to rising carbon dioxide because it is a C3 plant. This initial hypothesis proved correct: Schoenoplectus grew roughly 30 percent more biomass, and absorbed 32 percent more carbon dioxide, under the elevated CO2 treatment. Moreover, the benefit of elevated CO2 for plant growth has persisted over this long-term experiment.

Download data from CO2 project here

View all downloadable data from Global Change Research Wetland

The Future

Smithsonian scientists also expected the C3 Schoenoplectus to displace the C4 Spartina over time, because rising carbon dioxide favors C3 plants. However, this has not happened in nearly three decades. By running this experiment over many years, our team is beginning to understand the reasons for this unexpected result. We suspect that changes in global change factors other than carbon dioxide, such as sea level and nitrogen loading, favor the C4 plants. These insights have inspired new experiments at the Global Change Research Wetland.